01 February 2022

LGBT+ History Month: 2 key equality issues hopefully changing soon

01 February 2022

While LGBT+ History Month (lgbtplushistorymonth.co.uk) is an opportunity to look back at key moments in the fight for equality and the trailblazers who have come before, it’s also a chance to look forward.

The news cycle might paint quite a bleak picture of life in the LGBT+ community – particularly with recorded homophobic and transphobic hate crimes on the rise – but Nancy Kelley, chief executive of Stonewall (stonewall.org.uk), feels positive about the future.

“It’s my job to feel hopeful,” she says simply. “It’s my job to make sure to fight with others in the movement to make sure we get a positive outcome.”

Kelley adds: “It’s really relevant to LGBT History Month actually – I think a lot about Michael Cashman [one of the founders of Stonewall], Lisa Power [activist], Ian McKellen – I think about what they lived through, and what they did. I think about all the LGBTQ people that came before me, whose names we don’t know, because they weren’t famous activists – they were just incredibly brave people going about their daily lives, and insisting other citizens see them and recognize them as they are.

“I think about how much they were able to change, and that gives me enormous hope – not that we will win all the fights now, but that we will win all of the fights eventually… And we can all be part of making that happen.”

Kelley feels particularly positive when she considers how much has changed in her own lifetime – allowing her to now be married to a woman, and be an adopter – making her “think about the potential for change in the future for the lifetime of my children”.

While Kelley admits “things don’t get better on their own – we fight, and we fight together to make them better” – there are two particular issues she feels particularly hopeful will change in the near future…

Issue 1: Conversion therapy

“Conversion therapy, or so-called conversion therapy, are practices that are trying to change or suppress who we are at the basic level,” explains Kelley. “So they’re trying to make lesbian, gay, bi, ace [asexual] people’s sexual orientation change, they’re designed to make trans people’s gender identity change.”

Kelley says conversion therapy doesn’t work, “because these are really fundamental parts of who we are, and there’s a lot of evidence that they cause very significant long-term psychological harm”.

Stonewall’s CEO indicates there’s “a broader social value” to banning conversion therapy, because it “supports and underlines the idea that there’s something wrong with who we are – we’re beautiful just as we are”.

Kelley feels hopeful the UK government will implement a full ban soon, because “globally there is a campaign to end the abuse of conversion therapy gathering incredible pace”. Canada and France have already passed “comprehensive bans”, and although the process is “moving a lot slower” in the UK, she says: “The government has committed to bringing forward legislation, and has consulted on it.”

For Kelley, it’s important this legislation “doesn’t leave loopholes that allow for these really horrific abuses to continue” – giving the example of adults being able to ‘consent’ to conversion therapy as a potentially damaging caveat.

“What is absolutely clear is these practices should never have existed, and should certainly be relegated to the past,” she says. “Whatever happens with the consultation process [the government looking into how to implement a ban], there’s no doubt in my mind that the UK will end up with an effective ban of conversion therapy – whether this year or next.”

Issue 2: Unequal access to fertility treatment on the NHS

Kelley calls this “one of those areas of inequality that a lot of people don’t know exists – and unfortunately, when people discover it is often when it’s directly harming them”.

In England, access to fertility treatments differs depending on where you live, as NHS funding allocation is decided by local clinical commissioning groups (CCGs). This affects both LGBTQ+ and heterosexual couples, essentially resulting in a ‘postcode lottery’ – meaning you might get a lot luckier when trying for a family and needing treatment, depending on where you live.

For same-sex couples who want to have fertility treatment, many find they face the additional hurdle of having to privately pay for three to 12 rounds of IUI (intrauterine insemination, which has a lower success rate than IVF) before being offered one round of IVF on the NHS. This can be hugely expensive, costing up to £25,000.

“What that means, in effect, is only wealthy couples can access NHS IVF,” explains Kelley. “And this is just wrong… It shouldn’t be the case that money is a barrier to becoming a parent.

“So what we want is those guidelines to be changed [by NICE – the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence], we want for clinical commissioning groups in the meantime to step up” and provide free IUI treatments – as a small minority already do.

Ultimately, Kelley wants things to change “so couples are able to access IUI for free and then move onto IVF for free, and have an equal experience of attempting to form a family”.

She adds: “It should have been changed a decade ago, and it needs something now – it shouldn’t be put off for next week, next year. It’s something that needs action.

“From my perspective, LGBTQ+ people – we’re fantastic, loving family members, and we’re fantastic, loving parents. Parenting isn’t for all of us, it’s not what we all want. But for those of us that do want to become parents, we shouldn’t have this kind of financial barrier put in our way,” Kelley says – and she suggests it’s an easy, quick fix, so this is something that could very soon become a relic of the past.

The best videos delivered daily

Watch the stories that matter, right from your inbox