30 July 2021

Bezos loses appeal over Nasa’s plans to use Musk moon lander

30 July 2021

The US federal government has rejected an appeal by billionaire Jeff Bezos’s Blue Origin to get in on Nasa’s plans to return astronauts to the moon by using rival Elon Musk’s SpaceX

Nasa in April awarded the 2.9 billion dollar (£2 billion) contract for a lunar lander to the more established SpaceX, which also offered a cheaper price than the bids from Blue Origin and Dynetics, a subsidiary of Leidos.

The two losing companies appealed over the contract to the Government Accountability Office on the grounds that there should have been multiple contracts and that the proposals were not evaluated correctly, but the agency rejected their request.

The decision will allow “Nasa and SpaceX to establish a timeline for the first crewed landing on the moon in more than 50 years”, Nasa said in a statement on Friday, calling a moon landing a priority of the Biden administration.

The SpaceX prototype Starship hopper stands at the Boca Chica Beach site in Texas (Miguel Roberts/The Brownsville Herald via AP)

Friday’s ruling found that even though Nasa originally said it was going to give multiple contracts, it did not have enough money and that awarding only one contract was legal.

Plus, it found Nasa’s evaluation of all three bids “was reasonable, and consistent with applicable procurement law regulation and the announcement terms”, according to a statement by GAO lawyer Kenneth Patton.

SpaceX’s bid had the highest rating while the other bids “were significantly higher in price”, with the space agency deciding it could not afford to give out multiple contracts as originally planned, the GAO announcement said.

Blue Origin, which has been trying to get Congress to require a second lander contract, still hopes Nasa will change its mind and provide “simultaneous competition”, said company spokesperson Linda Mills.

“We stand firm in our belief that there were fundamental issues with Nasa’s decision, but the GAO was not able to address them due to their limited jurisdiction,” Ms Mills said in a statement.

“We continue to advocate for two immediate providers as we believe it is the right solution.”

The lunar lander is part of the agency’s beyond-Earth exploration plans, refocused on the moon by the Trump administration.

The Artemis programme involves a new huge rocket that would launch four astronauts aboard an Orion space capsule to the moon’s orbit.

The lander would take two astronauts to the moon’s surface, where they would explore for about a week, hook back up with Orion in lunar orbit and return to Earth.

The SpaceX lander, called Starship, “includes a spacious cabin” and can be expanded to a fully reusable launch system for travel to the moon, Mars and other places, Nasa said when it awarded the contract.

A test flight of the capsule, without astronauts aboard, is scheduled for this year, with a test flight by astronauts to the moon – but without a landing – planned for 2023, according to Nasa.

The best videos delivered daily

Watch the stories that matter, right from your inbox